Select Page

Folklore as Observable Science

What if some of our oldest stories are observations that have outlived their explanations? And what happens when we stop telling them?

I grew up in Ireland, where perfectly sensible people could tell you that a particular well had healing properties, that a certain place was best avoided, or that interfering with a fairy fort was asking for trouble.

Nobody necessarily offered a mechanism. They simply knew.

As a scientist, I find this deeply unsatisfactory. As an Irish woman, I find it entirely reasonable.

And the older I get, the more interested I become in the space between those two positions.

Before we had an explanation

Science begins with observation. Something happens. Someone notices. It happens again. Perhaps someone else notices too. Eventually, we begin to ask whether there is a pattern, and only then do we start looking for a mechanism.

We tend to associate this process with laboratories, instruments, carefully designed experiments and statistical analysis. But humans have been observing their environments for considerably longer than we have had laboratories.

For thousands of years, people needed to understand which plants were edible, which waters were safe, when animals behaved differently, and which environmental conditions preceded danger. They did not have access to molecular biology, analytical chemistry or sophisticated epidemiology.

They had observation, memory and stories.

I wonder whether some of what we now call folklore represents the preservation of observations that proved sufficiently important to survive across generations. Not necessarily because the explanations were correct, but because someone noticed something worth remembering.

N = 1, repeated over generations

Scientists are generally suspicious of anecdotal evidence, and quite rightly. A single observation cannot reliably establish causation.

A person drinks from a particular spring and subsequently recovers from an illness. Perhaps the water helped. Perhaps the illness was already resolving. Perhaps several other factors were involved. Perhaps the entire story became more impressive with each retelling.

An observation is not proof. But it can be the beginning of a question.

Now imagine that observations accumulate over generations. A grandmother notices something and tells her daughter. Her daughter observes something similar. The story is repeated, modified and passed on.

Eventually, the observation may become detached from the circumstances in which it first occurred. What survives is the instruction.

Drink from this well. Avoid that place. Do not eat those berries. Leave the fairy fort alone.

The original observation may have been quite ordinary. The explanation might have been entirely wrong. But the behaviour survives because the story is memorable.

This does not turn folklore into scientific evidence. Repetition through storytelling is not the same as independent replication, and stories can survive because they are frightening, entertaining or socially useful rather than factually accurate.

Still, it raises an interesting possibility.

Could folklore sometimes function as a form of community memory, preserving observations long after the reasoning behind them has disappeared?

The curious case of holy wells

Ireland has a remarkable tradition of holy wells. Some are associated with particular saints. Others have older histories or local traditions that are difficult to disentangle. People visited them for healing, protection or spiritual purposes, and certain wells became associated with particular ailments.

From a modern scientific perspective, it would be easy to dismiss these traditions as superstition. And perhaps many of the healing claims were just that.

But I find myself wondering about the water.

Water is not chemically identical everywhere. Its composition depends on geology, groundwater movement and the materials through which it passes. Some natural waters contain dissolved minerals and trace elements that differ substantially from those found elsewhere.

Could particular waters have influenced health under particular circumstances? Possibly.

Could a reported benefit simply reflect rest, ritual, social support, expectation or the natural course of illness? Absolutely.

Could a healing reputation have developed without any measurable therapeutic effect? Of course.

The point is not that holy wells possessed miraculous properties. The point is that the existence of a longstanding observation invites a question.

What was being observed? Was there anything unusual about the environment? Did the experience differ from what people ordinarily encountered? And if a pattern existed, what might explain it?

Those are scientific questions.

The folklore does not answer them. It simply gives us somewhere interesting to look.

The fairy fort problem

Then there are fairy forts.

Across Ireland, ancient earthworks and ringforts became associated with stories warning people against disturbing them. Interference might bring bad luck, illness or some other unpleasant consequence.

I am not proposing that fairies were conducting an early form of environmental regulation. Although, frankly, they might have achieved better compliance than some modern planning departments.

But the stories interest me.

A warning not to disturb a particular place can have consequences beyond its supernatural explanation. It may preserve a landscape feature, protect an old structure from destruction, or allow vegetation and habitat to persist in an otherwise modified environment.

Of course, this does not prove that ecological conservation was the original purpose of the stories. Ringfort traditions are historically and culturally complex, and many explanations for their survival are possible.

But the relationship between belief and behaviour is fascinating.

A community does not necessarily need to understand the ecological or archaeological value of a place for a tradition to influence how that place is treated.

The story changes behaviour. And changed behaviour can have material consequences.

Sometimes the explanation matters less than what the story causes people to do.

Observation is not explanation

There is a danger in romanticising traditional knowledge. The fact that something is old does not make it true, and the fact that generations believed something does not establish a biological mechanism.

Humans are extraordinarily good at noticing patterns. We are also extraordinarily good at finding patterns where none exist.

We remember unusual events, favour explanations that fit existing beliefs, repeat compelling stories and quietly forget the occasions when predictions fail.

Folklore is subject to all these limitations. Some traditions may preserve useful observations. Others may preserve mistaken assumptions, social rules, fear, prejudice or explanations that have no relationship to observable reality. Many will contain a mixture of these things.

That is precisely why I find the subject interesting.

The scientific response should not be to accept a claim because it is traditional. Nor should it automatically be to reject the underlying observation because the traditional explanation seems implausible.

We can separate the two.

What was observed? How consistently was it observed? What alternative explanations exist? Can we measure anything? Can the observation be reproduced under defined conditions?

The mechanism is a question to investigate, not something to invent retrospectively.

This distinction allows curiosity without abandoning scientific rigour.

The disappearing conversation

But perhaps there is something else we are losing.

Not just the stories. The conversations that carried them.

Folklore was rarely transmitted as a carefully curated collection of facts. It was shared between people, around kitchen tables, during visits, while working, over cups of tea, and in the ordinary spaces where people spent time together.

Someone would tell a story. Someone else would remember something similar. Another person would challenge it, embellish it or introduce a completely different explanation.

The story might change. The understanding might change with it.

And perhaps that was part of the process.

Knowledge was not simply being transferred from one person to another. It was being explored collectively.

I wonder whether we underestimate the intellectual value of these conversations because they produce no obvious output. There is no publication, no recorded metric, no deliverable. Sometimes there isn’t even a conclusion.

But something has happened.

An observation has been shared. An idea has been challenged. Two experiences that previously existed separately have become connected. Someone leaves the conversation thinking differently.

And this is where I start to worry about the systems we are creating.

We have become extraordinarily efficient at storing information. We can search millions of publications, retrieve data from across the world and generate summaries in seconds.

But access to information is not the same as the opportunity to make sense of it together.

In academia, we increasingly organise our interactions around predetermined outcomes. Meetings have agendas. Collaborations have deliverables. Conferences have tightly scheduled sessions. Conversations are squeezed between presentations.

Even curiosity can begin to feel like something that needs a business case.

Yet some of the most interesting intellectual connections emerge when nobody is trying particularly hard to make them happen. When someone says, “That reminds me of something,” and someone else replies, “That’s funny, because I’ve noticed…”

Perhaps the value of folklore was never simply the information contained within the story.

Perhaps it was also the social space the story created. A reason to gather, remember, compare observations, disagree, wonder and pass something on.

We have built remarkable systems for preserving the products of human thought.

I am less certain that we are preserving the conditions in which thinking happens.

What survives

There is another question that interests me. Why do some observations survive while others disappear?

In scientific research, we have journals, databases, repositories and formal systems for preserving information. Historically, communities relied much more heavily on memory, repetition and storytelling.

A useful observation was more likely to persist if it could be communicated, and a memorable story might travel further than a careful explanation.

Perhaps folklore can sometimes be understood as a form of compressed information. The details become simplified, the uncertainty disappears, the explanation changes, but the story survives.

Of course, this process can also distort information beyond recognition. A story passed down through generations is not a reliable dataset.

But perhaps it is a clue that something mattered enough for people to keep talking about it.

I find that thought rather wonderful.

And perhaps there is another layer to this. The stories that survived did not necessarily do so because someone carefully preserved them. They survived because people kept finding reasons to tell them.

The telling was part of their survival.

A story that nobody repeats eventually disappears, regardless of how useful the original observation may have been.

Which makes me wonder what happens when the spaces for these conversations disappear too.

The value of paying attention

I keep returning to the idea of N = 1.

One observation. One unexpected outcome. One person who notices something that does not quite fit.

In modern research, we rightly place enormous value on reproducibility, representative samples and statistical confidence. But discovery does not always begin with a dataset.

Sometimes it begins with someone noticing something peculiar.

The challenge is knowing what to do next.

An observation should not become a conclusion simply because it is intriguing. But neither should it be dismissed merely because it arrived without a hypothesis, a funding application or a plausible mechanism.

There is room between belief and dismissal. A space for curiosity.

For asking whether an old story might contain an observation worth investigating, while remaining perfectly comfortable with the possibility that it does not.

Perhaps that is what attracts me to folklore. It reminds me that people were observing the world long before we developed the tools to measure it.

They were trying to make sense of illness, landscapes, weather, plants, animals and human behaviour. Sometimes they were undoubtedly wrong. Sometimes they may have noticed something important.

And sometimes the story may be the only surviving trace of the question.

I do not think science needs to validate folklore. Nor does folklore need scientific validation to have cultural meaning. But I think there is something valuable in allowing the two to remain curious about one another.

Because observation often precedes understanding.

And occasionally, the explanation arrives centuries after someone first noticed that something strange was happening.

Perhaps the old stories are not telling us what to believe. Perhaps some of them are reminding us where to look.

But perhaps they are also reminding us of something else.

That knowledge does not always emerge from an individual sitting alone with information. Sometimes it emerges between people, in the telling, the questioning, the remembering and the occasional complete nonsense.

We have become very good at preserving the answers.

I wonder whether we are forgetting how to preserve the conversations.